The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping - Movie Review

While there is a certain weekend coming in December that may be among the biggest we've ever seen at the box office, November 20th is set to be a massive day at the movies. Only one major release is coming, but that major release happens to be the latest entry in the Hunger Games franchise. After Suzanne Collins' iconic initial trilogy, the story everyone seemed to want was the story of Haymitch's Hunger Games, and now nearly a decade and a half since the first Hunger Games movie hit theatres, Haymitch's story comes to the big screen with thunderous fanfare.

If you haven't read the book already, Sunrise on the Reaping follows a young Haymitch as he is thrown into the 50th Hunger Games and Second Quarter Quell. In honour of the big anniversary the games are given twice the tributes of typical years, 48 children fighting to the death rather than the typical 24. We get to see younger versions of countless franchise icons, as Haymitch trains to be District 12's second victor, and perhaps throw a wrench in the games themselves.

This is probably my favourite film in the franchise since Catching Fire. Haymitch has always been a character I love so getting his story here is a real treat, unless you like feeling joy. For a franchise whose central premise is so dark, this is the bleakest story we've gotten. Things do tie back in to the original films to quell some of the sadness, but prepare to be emotionally wrecked by Haymitch's story. While the attempt to lighten things up is a bit corny, the overall commitment to the bleakness of Sunrise on the Reaping is what really makes it work in my opinion. We get a fascinating look into the politics at play, planting the seeds of everything we see once Katniss and Peeta enter the fold 24 years later. Those politics make the lead up to the actual games some of the most exciting throughout any of the films. You care about the journey to the bloodbath just as much as the games themselves, whereas the series' previous entry Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes had a constant feeling of wanting more time with the actual games.

One of the biggest highlights here is the casting. This is a huge ensemble with countless younger versions of characters we know, and the vast majority of the new cast is incredible. Joseph Zada is a star in the making here as Haymitch, bringing some truly crushing emotion while also delivering a strong leading man. You can easily see the line from this version of the character to Woody Harrelson's portrayal, which allows the film as a whole to feel authentic as part of the series. The other massive hit in my opinion was Jesse Plemons as Plutarch, the role previously mastered by the great Phillip Seymour Hoffman. Similar to Zada, you can see a clear line from this version of the character to the one we get in Catching Fire, allowing Plemons to deliver a performance that is fully his own but with clear nods to where the character will end up. We also get Kelvin Harrison Jr. as a young Beetee, brilliantly mastering Jeffrey Wright's specific mannerisms, Elle Fanning bringing the brightness of Effie Trinket with a younger twist, and a duo of Maya Hawke and Lili Taylor as Wiress and Mags that bring a bit extra to characters we didn't get to know too well previously. At the head of the table is the series' overarching antagonist President Snow, brought to life chillingly by Ralph Fiennes. Donald Sutherland is a wildly tough act to follow, but Fiennes is simply one of the best in the business and his performance is at times honestly kind of terrifying. The only real miss in terms of new takes on old characters is Kieran Culkin as Caesar Flickerman, still bringing an eccentric energy, but lacking the class that Stanley Tucci brought to the role in lieu of what essentially just feels like Kieran Culkin.

While the long list of new takes on old characters is a big draw, there are also plenty of new additions that shine. Chief among them is likely McKenna Grace as Maysilee Donner, one of the female tributes from District 12. Grace brings a real edge to her performance here that makes her quietly ferocious, and the weight she brings to her character's more emotional moments make her a clear standout. The other District 12 tributes are played by Ben Wang and Molly McCann, each of whom bring a charm and youthfulness that really just makes you emotional knowing what they're about to be put through. We also get Whitney Peak as Haymitch's love interest Lenore Dove, giving us a strong voice and someone you can feel Haymitch fighting for throughout the games. Lastly there's the iconic Glenn Close as Drusilla Sickle, the escort for District 12 from the reaping ceremony up to the games. In the original films this was Effie's job, so seeing someone with none of that warmth she brought is a sharp contrast but one Close nails. The makeup effects done on her help the cause, but she is truly unsettling in the best way.

The cast is far from the only highlight, this is also a beautifully crafted film from a production standpoint. It's genuinely shocking how close to what I pictured when I read the book, basically everything from the games themselves feel like they were taken straight from my head which is major praise for any adaptation. The set design brilliantly manages to be drab and dreary one moment then bright and vibrant the next, and the costumes fit a similar mold. The cinematography also has some very strong moments throughout, and James Newton Howard delivers another great score.

I do have some issues with the narrative and pacing. While I enjoyed the ending as a fan of the series, it is a really cheesy, to the point where I think it kind of cuts away from the emotional heft of the film. Like Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes this entry also struggles with the tone once we get out of the games, having a bit too much extra tacked on afterwards rather than letting the climax linger. There were some points in the opening act that felt a bit too drawn out, and elements of the training for the games that I think could have used a bit more time to develop. On the whole though, I was very satisfied by this one and it stands tall as a massive event film for the fall season. 4/5



Comments